As we’ve already reported, yesterday Virginia Foxx declared that she would be filing for a recount in her race against Democratic candidate Chuck Hubbard for North Carolina’s District 5 congressional race. Today, she formalized that request with the NCSBE.
So in addition to ensuring you know she made the cutoff (the State Board had her request posted by about 9:20 a.m. Tuesday, ahead of the noon deadline), we thought it might be helpful to pose a few questions about why she may be doing this.
Does Rep. Foxx legitimately believe there is a glimmer of hope yet for her in this campaign? In her letter to the NCSBE she cited only the margin, 331 votes, which she says is less than 1 percent of the votes cast. In her statement Monday she called it "razor thin," "1 out of every 1,000 ballots cast," and, per the Watauga Democrat, pointed to counting errors in Georgia, Idaho and Virginia. Does Rep. Foxx have an insatiable hunger to stay in the limelight? Does she believe that, at 83 years old, she still has some fight left in her? Maybe she isn’t ready to fill up her newly found spare time seeing how far she can take Olive Garden’s endless pasta option. We’re betting she’s got her ID ready.
In our research, recounts almost never flip a result. FairVote counted 37 complete statewide recounts from 2000 through 2025. Only three changed the winner, and all three started with a margin under 0.06 percent. Hubbard’s lead is about 0.12 percent.
Perhaps she believes that there is some value to keeping her constituency engaged. She’s already said she will run again no matter what in 2028, per her fundraising message to supporters, and she has filed a statement of candidacy with the FEC for 2028.
At this point, only she knows the real motive.
What happens next? As we’ve said, the NCSBE says the machine recount should be done by November 23rd, and the State Board meets November 24th to consider certification. Each county board feeds every ballot in the race back through the tabulators. After the first recount, the trailing candidate has 24 hours to ask for a hand-to-eye count of a random 3 percent of precincts and early voting sites. If extrapolating that sample would flip the result, the whole district gets counted by hand. In Watauga County, the Board of Elections will hold the recount at 10 a.m. Wednesday, Nov. 18, at 814 W. King Street, according to a meeting notice from elections director Matt Snyder. The same meeting covers the District 35 judge race, and the public may attend, though space may be limited. The Watauga Democrat reports it will likely take at least two days.
Chuck has said he is ready to follow the process. Given all of the above, the chips look likely to fall his way, which would make Hubbard the first Democrat to represent this district since 1995. That’s one more interesting ripple in the blue tsunami.
We’ll keep you posted as the NCSBE reports.